The #1 reason top D2D sales reps leave is compensation. Not the work, not the hours, not the weather — the pay structure. A bad comp plan punishes your best performers, rewards mediocrity, and creates a revolving door that costs you more in recruiting and training than you would ever spend on a better commission structure. A good comp plan does the opposite: it attracts experienced reps, motivates consistent effort, and makes your top performers feel like leaving would cost them money.
This guide breaks down the most common D2D compensation models, explains when each one works, and gives you real numbers by industry so you can design a plan that fits your business.
The rep earns a fixed amount or percentage per sale. No base pay, no guaranteed income. They eat what they kill.
Pros: Zero fixed labor costs for the company. Attracts self-motivated, experienced reps who are confident in their ability. Easy to calculate and administer.
Cons: Extremely difficult to recruit new reps. High turnover in the first 2 to 4 weeks because reps who cannot close fast enough leave (or starve). Creates a feast-or-famine mentality that encourages aggressive, short-term selling behavior.
Best for: Established teams with experienced reps who know the product and territory. Not recommended for companies trying to grow their team or hire entry-level reps.
The rep receives a small guaranteed base salary plus a commission on every sale. The base covers minimum living expenses; the commission provides upside.
Pros: Much easier to recruit because the base reduces risk for the rep. Lower early turnover because new reps can survive the learning curve. Attracts a broader talent pool including people who might not take a pure commission role.
Cons: Higher fixed costs for the company. Requires careful calibration — too high a base and reps get comfortable; too low and it does not actually help with recruiting.
Best for: Companies that are scaling, hiring entry-level reps, or entering new markets. The base should be enough to cover basic expenses (typically $400 to $800 per week) but low enough that commission is still the primary income driver.
The commission rate increases as the rep hits higher sales thresholds. For example: 10 percent on the first 10 sales, 15 percent on sales 11 through 20, and 20 percent on sales 21+.
Pros: Rewards your best performers disproportionately, which is exactly what you want. Creates natural acceleration — the more a rep sells, the more each additional sale is worth, which incentivizes pushing through the end of the month instead of coasting.
Cons: More complex to calculate and communicate. Can feel unfair to lower performers who never reach the higher tiers.
Best for: Mid-size and larger teams where you want to separate top performers from average performers and reward the difference explicitly.
The rep receives a guaranteed weekly draw (advance) that is later deducted from earned commissions. If the rep earns more in commission than the draw, they keep the difference. If they earn less, they owe the deficit (recoverable draw) or it is forgiven (non-recoverable draw).
Pros: Gives new reps income stability during the ramp-up period while maintaining a commission-first structure. The company recovers the draw if the rep performs, so the net cost is low.
Cons: Recoverable draws can create debt stress for struggling reps, accelerating their exit. Non-recoverable draws are essentially a base salary with extra steps. Administration is more complex.
Best for: Companies that want the recruiting benefit of a base but prefer to maintain a commission-only culture long-term. Use a non-recoverable draw for the first 30 to 60 days as a training draw, then transition to pure commission.
| Industry | Avg Commission Per Sale | Monthly Earnings (Avg Rep) | Common Structure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pest Control | $80 – $150 | $4,000 – $8,000 | Commission-only or draw |
| Solar | $500 – $1,500 | $6,000 – $15,000 | Base + commission or tiered |
| Roofing | $300 – $800 | $5,000 – $12,000 | Commission-only or tiered |
| Home Security | $150 – $400 | $5,000 – $10,000 | Draw or base + commission |
| Fiber Internet | $75 – $200 | $4,000 – $8,000 | Base + commission |
| Landscaping | $30 – $75 | $3,000 – $6,000 | Base + commission or hourly + bonus |
These numbers represent a rep working a full schedule (5 to 6 days per week, 6 to 8 hours of door time). Top performers in every industry earn 2 to 3 times the average. Bottom performers earn less than minimum wage on a per-hour basis, which is why retention is so closely tied to comp structure.
If you promote reps into management roles, you need an override structure that compensates them for building and coaching a team. The most common approaches:
Flat override per rep sale. The manager earns a fixed amount ($10 to $50) on every sale made by a rep on their team. Simple to calculate and understand. Works well for small teams of 3 to 8 reps.
Percentage override. The manager earns a percentage (3 to 10 percent) of each rep's commission. This scales naturally with deal size and is common in solar and roofing where commissions vary significantly by project.
Personal + team hybrid. The manager earns a reduced personal commission on their own sales plus an override on team sales. This keeps managers knocking doors alongside their team, which is critical for coaching and credibility. Typical split: 70 percent of normal personal commission + 5 percent override on team sales.
Bonus triggers for managers. Add bonuses for hitting team-level targets: "If your team closes 50+ deals this month, you earn a $2,000 team bonus on top of overrides." This aligns the manager's incentive with team performance, not just individual rep output.
Your compensation plan is the single most important tool you have for attracting, motivating, and retaining D2D sales talent. Design it with the same rigor you apply to your sales process, and it will pay for itself many times over through reduced turnover, higher performance, and a reputation that makes recruiting easier every season.
14-day free trial. No credit card required. Import your list and start knocking doors in under 10 minutes.
Start Free Trial